Online with
Louise Ripley

 
Gender Issues in Management
Sports & The Military

Return to Course Syllabus
 
Sports
In the Unit on Language we saw how sports language is so prevalent in management and business. It also shapes how we view the world. I still tell women aspiring to succeed in male-dominated fields to learn something about sports. You don't have to follow them all; pick one you can enjoy. Mine are baseball, Canadian football (a much better game than the American one!), and hockey during the play-offs, especially if the Leafs ever make it again. 

I have met women who refuse to learn anything about sports, or the military, because that's "men's stuff" and why should we learn it? There are good reasons to know something about sports, in addition to being able to talk the language that so many male managers speak.

A common sentiment in sports can build good-will in other areas. The guy who knows you were as desolate as he was when the Jays traded away Matt Stairs  in 2008 will be much more likely to support you in a departmental battle. I know this one works; I used it.

There is also a lesson here for managers, for leaders. Sometimes you make your own justice in the world, in the workplace, and you do it through hard work and teamwork. Matt Stairs didn't go grumbling and complaining to his new team and sit on the bench moping. He got right down to work, did his very best (as he always tried to do), played as a team player, got some hits that drove in runs (RBIs) and eventually hit the home run for the Philadelphia Phillies that enabled them to go to the World Series, which they ended up winning! Matt Stairs will now proudly wear a World Series ring.  

Even advertisements show an awareness of how important sports can be to a woman's career. The picture of what "the corporate ladder actually looks like" is accompanied by the words:  

"More and more, the golf course is becoming the boardroom of the 21st century. And to help you make the most of it, we've introduced Links for Women Golf School. It takes place over a fun-filled day and is designed exclusively for women to learn golf in a fun, social and supportive environment. And whether you shoot 90 or 190, it's perfect for all levels of play. One day courses take place in cities all across Canada. For the city nearest you or for more information, call 1-877-754-4653 or visit us at  www.linksforwomengolf.com.

[Warning: if you click on the link to "linksforwomengolf" you will have to use the down arrow in your "back" button to get back here)

The sponsors are: 

Exercise
Golf Anyone?
Why do you think that so many women who aspire to upper management jobs are learning golf, whether or not they really have an urge to learn to play the game?

Another reason to know something about sports is that there are so many excellent examples of good (and poor) management and leadership in sports. For an excellent look at how sports can help us better understand these fields, read:  

Carter, David M. and Darren Rovell (2003) On the Ball: What You Can Learn About Business From America's Sports Leaders. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Education Division of Prentice Hall Publishing.

Women’s general lack of knowledge and appreciation of sports starts with our earliest upbringing and socialization. Little girls play games that emphasize individual skill, like jacks and hopscotch; or we play non-competitive games like "House" while the little boys are playing on teams, learning all about the teamwork that makes up most of business.

On teams, boys learn to be aggressive and competitive and to take charge. They learn respect for authority, whether it’s the coach or the boss. They learn that winning is the object of the game but there has to be a reasonable test of skill.

They learn good sportsmanship, which helps them handle failure and take defeat in stride. They learn how to play a position on a team and how to work for the success of the team, which helps them understand in business that ultimately it is not personal success but the success of the company that advances you.

They learn that although there are rules, there also are acceptable ways to break those rules, and that management often expects you to break those rules. Boys learn that much of the fun of any game, including business, is in pushing the limits within the confines of the rules, which later allows them to enjoy management as the ultimate test of their skill within the boundaries.

There is major disagreement in feminist circles as to whether women need to learn to play the game the way that boys do growing up, or just make a complete new set of rules. I fall somewhere in between. A complete set of new rules is never possible to do overnight; while we're working on them, it's not a bad idea to learn to speak the language of those who have held power longer. 

Exercise
Sports Heroes
Describe a work-related situation where it would be a good thing for a woman to know who Roy Halliday is, or what it means when someone talks about Paul Henderson scoring THE GOAL, and why the Olympic Gold Medal after 50 years was so crucial to Canadians in February of 2002. Why does a manager particularly need some knowledge of sports? 

The Military

Lessons From The Military

Most men, even if they have not served in the armed forces, are also socialized to some extent by a knowledge or understanding of the military, even if only through watching war movies. Learn from the lessons of the military what can work for you in management.

Lesson One  Respect for the chain of command
You obey your commanding officer simply because he is your commanding officer and outranks you, regardless of how you feel about him personally and even regardless of his competence. 

Women who recognize this kind of behaviour in men they work with can use it to their advantage. Speak a language he understands. You don't have to like it or agree with it, just to recognize that many men respond naturally to it. Management styles are changing in the 1990's, but for most of your working career, there will still be a large number of men out there who think in military terms. Don't cry about it! Use it.

If your tyrannical boss constantly takes your ideas as his own, the rules of the game say you can't go over his head to his commanding officer to complain and you can't sabotage the project just to get even, not if you're a company woman and plan to rise through the ranks. You have three choices: you can buckle under and obey, you can quit, or you can work to try to change things but with respect for the man's position. Don't risk your own career trying to do side-step lines of authority. Unless you work in a place with a strong labour union or a university with tenure, nothing will finish your chances for promotion faster. 

You can use his archaic male-dominated military style thinking to your advantage. If you are a manager with a subordinate male worker who won't do what you say, don't get angry, don't feel hurt and frustrated, let him know that he is to follow your orders simply because you are in charge. 

You do this either in direct words or, more often, by your attitude, your carriage, your way of speaking to him that reminds him of the military lessons he knows almost intuitively, whether he's ever served in the forces or not, that he must respect your orders simply because you are his superior officer.

Exercise
Chain of Command
What have you learned about the Chain of Command from being a student that you can carry into management in the work world? 

Lesson Two  One of the best lessons from the military is the wonderful phrase, that I learned from my colleague Leo Gallant, an Accounting professor in the St. Francis Xavier's School of Business: 

Choose Your Hill To Die On

Not all battles can be won; not all hills can be taken; not all battles are worth the cost of winning; not all hills can be taken without sustaining grievous losses; sometimes your troops or your artillery are not up to the fight. A strategic retreat beats an inglorious defeat any day. There ARE some battles you must fight, some hills on which you will be willing to stand and die before you will give it up. But choose these verrrrrry carefully! In military terms, you only have one life to give to your country. In management terms, you only have limited resources and energy. 

Lesson Three  Respect for the trappings of authority

Stripes, badges, medals. Don't miss out on them. Don't underestimate their importance. They identify the important players, and distinguish their positions. Too often, women say 'thank you' to a salary and title without a second thought to what else they ought to get. If you are a manager and other managers all have an office with a window and a view, you need one too. If other Vice Presidents get memberships in the country club, you need one too. If other senior managers get a signing bonus when they come aboard, you need one too, or you will simply not be seen as a serious player.

Lesson Four  Learn to Take Risks

Another thing that boys are raised with, better than most girls, is learning how to take risks. If you want to succeed in life, you have to take some risks.

In order to succeed, either on the battlefield or in life, one sometimes must take some risk. Women aren't generally raised to take risks, and even when we do, we don't recognize it or admit it. I've spoken at many workshops where I've heard women say things like, 
"I'm not a risk taker, not at all," then two minutes later, she's telling you, "Two years ago, I left an abusive marriage in Calgary, picked the kids up one night and hitched a ride to Toronto with a neighbour; didn't know anyone here, but I managed to get a job, get the kids into school, and now we're all doing pretty well." (true story). A pretty brave woman, even if she's not willing to call herself a risk taker. I did this for years -- insisted I was not a risk taker. Then I began to take a look at my life! 

For most of us, it's better to practice risk taking first in relatively safe places. Don't just go into your boss' office tomorrow morning and threaten to leave if he doesn't shape up. That may be a little too much risk all at once. Practice in small ways first. A good way is to practice doing things that traditionally have been done mostly by men, or things that have terrified you, or which you believed you could never do. 

I learned to change an electric light fixture in my kitchen, not the bulb, but the actual fixture, when my husband was laid up with a broken leg. I am almost as proud of that light fixture as I am of my doctoral degree that hangs around the corner from it in the hall. 

When I was on my first sabbatical, I learned to drive a John Deere Tractor. I have a little model of that tractor that sat on my desk for years. I used to take it with me to difficult department meetings (all of them) to remind myself that no one would mess with someone who could control all that power. Click on the link to see me on my tractor.
I also have a rabbit's foot, but it's got too long and difficult a tale (pun intended) attached to it to tell here on the Internet. Suffice it to say that you can see here that it doesn't have that little metal ring on the end like the ones you buy ready-made, and it represents one of the riskiest but best things I ever did in my life. 

It's good to push the limits of risk if you're traditionally a non- or low-risk taker, but don't over do it; don't fall for the general belief touted in so many business magazines that you have to climb the bottom half of Mt. Everest or go white water rafting in order to experience risk and thereby live life to its fullest. Take risks where you must and where you think you can succeed, but don't over do it. 

Exercise
Risk 
Think about a time you did something really risky, but which turned out well and was important to you in terms of your progress at work or school. What symbol might you put on your desk to remind you of how much you can do if you really want to? 

 

WebPages in this Unit
Early Women in Business Media
Language Sports and the Military

Return To Course Syllabus

AK/ADMS/WMST3120 3.0 Gender Issues in Management
York University, Toronto
© M. Louise Ripley, M.B.A., Ph.D.